»

About the same, or even faster

John Gruber writes about hardware (i.e. physical) keyboards on mobile phones. I mostly agree with him on this one: they are, for the most part, useless and the iPhone is — at least — not hurt (in my view much better off) without one. There are, of course, some distinct advantages to having any form of physical controls on a device, including using the device without looking at it, but there are several drawbacks too, while at the same time the numerous advantages to having an on-screen ‘virtual’ keyboard more than make up for the lack of a physical one, both for design and usability reasons. In the end it’s probably a personal preference thing, but I for one have been waiting for an all-screen, no-keyboard device like the iPhone for years and I’m sure happy it’s here the way it is.

Oh and by the way, I probably type faster (and more accurately) on my iPhone than I would ever type on a BlackBerry device or Pré with their miniature keys that seem designed for children and the relatively tacky feel; it took less than a few days after getting my iPhone to getting used to the auto-correction system and a few more days before my typing performance stabilised to an acceptable level for dealing with emailing etc. Finally, the auto-correction on the iPhone seems to work admirably well with Greek too [for those eager to remind everyone that Apple has a parochial mindset; it does, but it doesn't apply here].

One Response to “About the same, or even faster”

  1. Kostis says:

    I definitely agree that the iPhone is much better off without a physical keyboard.

    But I strongly disagree with Gruber’s statement that iPhone users are probably roughly just as fast, maybe a bit slower but probably not by much than BlackBerry users with a physical keyboard.

    Having used both fairly extensively, there is no doubt in my mind that the BB physical keyboard is a far superior device for entering text. I love the iPhone auto-correction, and it does work great in Greek, but there’s just no way you’re going to get to BB levels of speed with a virtual keyboard.

    As I said above though, entering text is not the only thing a phone is supposed to do. Overall, I much prefer the iPhone’s virtual keyboard too. Overall it certainly blows the BB away as a device and I don’t think it ever will get a physical keyboard not suffer for it.

    Still, I hope I always also have a BB by my side for the times I need to be furiously typing work emails while walking in and out of public transportation, down the street, or up and down stairs.

Have your say.

Write in the language of the post. Comments are meant to encourage on-topic discussion. For general comments, observations, complaintsd (e.g. about the site), you can use the form found in the Contact page. Make sure you've read the Terms of Use before commenting.

Comments Feed for this post Comments Feed for this entry.

Download Spinalonga's Podsafe rock music for your podcast. From Athens, Greece, with love.'