Ross Anderson writes about how the newly elected ‘coalition’ government in the UK plans to proceed with a controversial plan to mandate the installation of Deep Packet Inspection kits at ISPs in that country. I’ve written about DPI in the past, how it affects our liberty and provides little, to no, advantages for safeguarding national security. A few years ago Hellas was one of the best countries to live in, in terms of privacy; that was more due to the fact that the country has practically little to no governance where it comes to security than due to liberty and privacy respecting government agencies. DPI has been proposed under the pretext of national security and economic purposes (piracy fighting, bandwidth optimisation) and the technology has — for a several years now — allowed relatively cheap devices to be installed to practically all medium-sized or larger ISPs.
I’d like to hope that sanity will prevail, but in a post 9/11 world civil liberties are not exactly a priority.
Does Parliament Control the Government or Do The Whips Control MPs?
Ίσως η πιο σημαντική, η πιο καίρια ερώτηση που μπορεί να κάνει κανείς σε μια δημοκρατία. Η απάντηση, του Βρετανού σοσιαλιστή του ‘παλαιού’ Labour, Tony Benn, προφανώς αφορά τη Βρετανία, μια χώρα γεμάτη πολιτικές αντιθέσεις που όμως χωρίς αμφιβολία έχει ένα σαφώς δημοκρατικότερο σύστημα από αυτό της Ελλάδος. Αναφέρεται στο κομματικό μαστίγιο [whip], την δική μας ‘κομματική γραμμή’, τη βουλευτική ισχύ (ή την έλλειψη αυτής) πάνω στις αποφάσεις και τις προτάσεις της κυβέρνησης. Ο Benn είναι γνωστός αριστερός πολιτικός στη Βρετανία· η ερώτησή του αυτή όμως δεν έχει σχέση με τον σοσιαλισμό. Θα μπορούσε να είναι κάλλιστα ερώτηση επερχόμενη από κάποιον φιλελεύθερο ή συντηρητικό πολιτικό.
Πριν από κάποιους μήνες το θέμα απσχόλησε αρκετά τους Βρετανούς, με αφορμή το ‘σκάνδαλο’ που ξέσπασε με τα έξοδα των βουλευτών. Κάποιοι τόλμησαν να πούν πως ένα σκάνδαλο όπως αυτό ίσως και έφερνε το τέλος του ‘μαστιγίου’ στη βουλή των Άγγλων. Κι’όμως παρατηρώντας το υπάρχον σύστημα τους, με τα σημαντικά προβλήματα και ελλείψεις του, είναι ένα καθολικά ανώτερο σύστημα από το δικό μας.
»
Towards a thoroughly electronic Police State. As if more cameras per capita than any place in the world were not enough, the UK’s frightening databases on…well, practically everything are handsomely presented by the Beeb. And some of the data there is, apparently, stored illegally. It’s surprising why this is not a cover story on the BBC web site. Does Britain really want its government to know so much?
Those that have been reading this site for a while know that I’m all for curtailing smoking in public places. Living in Hellas, a country where non-smokers are forced to inhale third-party smoke daily, my sentiments often become somewhat strong. Yet, fining a freelance painter for smoking in his own (private) van while going to work is stupid, wrong and — if anything — provides ample ammunition to those that try to portray smoking bans as discriminatory or controversial.
Smoking bans, to the extent that they ensure smoke-free public spaces are good. This kind of overly zealous enforcement of a vague (at best) law isn’t. I hope this guy takes them to court and wins.
ADSL in Greece revisited once again.
I was just about ready to go to bed when I read this transcript from a session in the Greek Parliament regarding ADSL. (it is in Greek). I thought it is time to revisit the subject.
I’ve got ADSL in Greece since this summer when it was announced. I can safely say that for as long as I used it (i.e. while I was there) the service was okay, albeit at a very high cost.
The obligatory purchase of a modem from OTE costing around €200 (cf. the Netgear DG834G 802.11g AP/Router/ADSL modem/4port switch in the UK which costs considerably less) — imposed presumably due to the financial interests of the company as well as the incompatibilities arising from the use of inferior Intracom/Alcatel/Siemens DSLAM devices in many exchanges as well as the very high cost of connectivity (more than €70 + VAT for a 384/128Kbps connection) still make is prohibitive for the Greek market.
Many people here (in the UK) believe that the UK too is lagging behind in the internet connectivity/access ratings. And indeed maybe it does, compared to countries like France, Germany, Italy and of course most of the Scandinavian ones. But if the UK is lagging behind, Greece must look like a Genuine Third World Country (if not a zoo) and certainly not an EU country that will host the 2004 Olympics.
In the middle of the summer I sent a letter to the Hellenic Oftel (EETT) regarding the situation touching upon the price, equipment provision and service availability of broadband connectivity in Greece and they too gave me a standard content-free reply that avoided to touch upon any of the issues I had enquired about and merely gave reassurances regarding the Committee’s efforts.
With ADSL having been overdue for three years before being finally widely available for the public this summer, extremely high prices, clueless technicians, lack of choice in modems and slow speed options (compared to the rest of Europe and the US) one would definitely expect a different (more apologetic) response from the people in charge of this fiasco. I just cannot believe how someone in the highest position of the Telecommunications Ministry and with the burden of this ridiculous state of connectivity in Greece falling upon his shoulders for the most part, can be so arrogant, ignorant and corrupt and still have no sense of dignity that would lead to his resignation, even when others (from any political background/party, social group etc.) specifically and accurately criticise the governments fundamental faults and indifference in dealing with such important issues like this.
It’s a different world.


