»  Naïve Brilliance

If anything can be said in retrospect about Robert McNamara is not that he was hawkish, evil, corrupt or duplicitous, but that despite his sophistication, the statistical prowess and scientific rigour that he showed in his work, his all-around intellectual capacity (or perhaps, in a way just because of all these) he exemplified the naïve brilliance that often accompanies highly intelligent people that fail to take that macroscopic view and consider where they place their focus and energy and why they do so. His 2003 ‘apology’ film, the Errol Morris documentary ‘The Fog Of War’, as well as his 1995 ‘In Retrospect’ book, both indicate that wisdom came late to McNamara; a clear and very welcome difference, nevertheless, to most of his contemporaries.

comments

» Beyond any doubt.

My grandmother was ill in bed when the Nazis came to her home town .. a German soldier shot her dead in her bed.

My grandmother did not die to provide cover for Israeli soldiers murdering Palestinian grandmothers in Gaza.

The present Israeli government ruthlessly and cynically exploit the continuing guilt from gentiles over the slaughter of Jews in the Holocaust as justification for their murder of Palestinians.

How true, this last paragraph. And how brilliant a statement, not because of its content, but because of who said it, Sir Gerald Kaufman, a British-Jew, raised as an Orthodox Jew and Zionist, a British MP from Manchester.

It’s about time to disassociate criticism against the Israeli military action in Gaza as an example of anti-semitism, bigotry, hatred or racism. Sure, those exist, but criticising a totally disproportional, non-discriminating military operation that targets civilians and Hamas militants alike with white phosphorus and bombards hospitals has nothing to do with it.

comments


2009.01.06

Waltz with Bashir (2008)

Waltz with Bashir, Movie PosterΤο περασμένο Σάββατο ήταν ημέρα κινηματογράφου και, έχωντας πρόσφατα δει τους Τρείς Πιθήκους, μια σαφώς υπερτιμημένη, πλην όμως αρκετά καλή ταινία, επισκεφθήκαμε τον Δαναό για την προβολή του ‘Βάλς με τον Μπασίρ’, μια από τις λίγες ταινίες που αξίζει να δείτε στους ελληνικούς κινηματογράφους αυτή την εποχή.

Το ‘βαλς’ επιχειρεί μια ιδιαίτερα πρωτότυπη προσέγγιση ενός τρομακτικά δύσκολου θέματος, μέσα από ένα απαιτητικό μέσο και απευθυνόμενη — κυρίως — σε ένα προβληματισμένο, εαν όχι σκεπτικό κοινό. Πραγματεύεται την ‘επέμβαση’ του Ισραήλ στον Λιβανέζικο εμφύλιο στις αρχές της δεκαετίας του 1980 και συγκεκριμένα τις σφαγές στους παλαιστινιακούς καταυλισμούς στη Ṣabrā και τη Shātīlā από τους ‘φαλαγγίτες’ χριστιανούς λιβανέζους. Σφαγές που έγιναν με την έμμεση αποδοχή/ανοχή (εαν όχι ενθάρρυνση) των Ισραηλινών και που απασχόλησαν τόσο την Κνεσσέτ όσο και τη διεθνή κοινότητα.
»

comments

2008.08.08

Point of No Return

I had no intention of writing anything about the conflict in South Ossetia, but it turns out it escalated much faster — and to a higher degree — than I (or anyone for that matter) expected. So much that for most of the mainstream media — and a couple of blogs I’m following — it totally overshadowed the massively promoted Olympics in Beijing.

The Russian involvement is certain to cause further escalation and I fear that no matter how international pressure might push towards a speedy cease-fire, the damage and cost (human or otherwise) is going to be huge for everyone involved. Long term instability in the region in the coming months (or even years) cannot be ruled out with any certainty.

What’s very interesting are the backstage politics: the timing of the attacks, the Russian intervention, Georgian expectations and reactions, the reaction of the West.

In an interview to CNN, Saakashvili, the Georgian president claimed that Russia had been planning the attack and building towards it through provocations and skirmishes for a while now. The idea he’s putting forward is that the combination of last February’s unilateral declaration of independence by Kossovo and its subsequent recognition by most of the West, the fact that it’s August (a time of year when most people are either on holidays), the ongoing Olympics in China and the upcoming US elections would make it easier for the Russians to use military force in order to occupy South Ossetia and strengthen the military capability of the separatists — an undoubted catalyst towards full autonomy. All this makes sense, but on the other hand, many of the same reasons could be why Georgia might risk attacking S.Ossetia itself: if Georgian military action in South Ossetia went unnoticed and unchallenged, they could, in theory, ‘resolve’ the issue and create a regional precedent that would certainly make Abkhazia’s efforts for independence much harder.

With both sides playing the propaganda game and accusing each other of provocations and aggression, it is impossible to discern what is really happening in the area; the stakes are too high for both Russia and Georgia, although from the look of things it wouldn’t be in Georgian interests to initiate a full-scale military operation in the region, so either they gambled (foolishly and at a huge risk) or they were attacked by Russia as Saakashvili claims. Still, no matter who started the conflict, I’m afraid that today’s escalation through the Russian use of bombers within Georgian territory — as reported by many western media — as well as the incursion of more than 150 Russian tanks in South Ossetia means that the point of no return before full-scale war is near.

Update: A Fist Full Of Euros has a more comprehensive account of what’s happening. Worth a read.

16 comments


» Στρατιωτική Πρόβα με την αποδοχή της Ελλάδος;

Το BBC δημοσιεύει άρθρο στο οποίο, σύμφωνα με δηλώσεις αξιωματικού των ΗΠΑ, στις αρχές Ιουνίου έγιναν πολεμικές ασκήσεις στο ‘ανατολικό Αιγαίο και πάνω από την Ελλάδα’ από την Ισραηλινή Αεροπορία στα πλαίσια προετοιμασίας για επίθεση στο Ιράν. Καθ’ότι δεν διαβάζω ελληνικό τύπο δε γνωρίζω εαν έγινε ή όχι αναφορά στη τηλεόραση/εφημερίδες. Αν μη τι άλλο θεωρώ πως — δεδομένης της ελληνικής θέσης — η όποια συμμετοχή της Ελλάδος σε πολεμικές προετοιμασίες πιθανής επίθεσης στο Ιράν είναι αν μη τι άλλο ηθικά και νομικά επίμαχη. Με άλλα λόγια, εαν ισχύει, δηλαδή η Έλλάδα παραχώρησε τον εθνικό εναέριο χώρο στο Ισραήλ για τέτοιες ασκήσεις, θαρρώ πως βρίσκεται σίγουρα εκτός των υποχρεώσεων μας ως μέλη του ΝΑΤΟ και σύμμαχος του Ισραήλ, είναι αντίθετο με την μέχρι σήμερα εξωτερική πολιτική της χώρας αλλά — πρωτίστως — τη βούληση των ελλήνων για διπλωματική λύση του ζητήματος των πυρηνικών εγκαταστάσεων στο Ιράν.

1 comments

» It may well turn out to be the largest war profiteering in history.

There’s no doubt about it: the war had its critics, and there were many of them, even before it became a mainstream affair, in late 2002; much like the ‘discussion’ about an attack on Iran is today, there were those that foresaw what was about to unfold. Over the years much has been said or written about the corruption, the unbelievable cost, the blatant disregard not just of the life of Iraqis, arguably of little importance to the leaders, military or political, of the US, but of the domestic social and economic impact of the war within the United States.

Few had any significant evidence to back it up. BBC’s Panorama investigates the matter and claims that up to $25 billion (€16.2 billion) of the budget allocated by the US Congress to the rebuilding of Iraq may have been ‘lost, stolen or not properly accounted for’. At the same time, a gag order in the US prevents anyone from discussing it. Even if no political argument, no humanistic, ideological or ethical platform of discussion is capable of penetrating those thick enough not capable of comprehending the severity, futility and cost of this war, I’m hoping that the economics of a dwindling US economy are in the coming US elections in November.

comments


2008.05.30

Bletchley Park to close?

Bletchley Park

In 2000 I visited what is probably one of the most interesting attractions for geeky history buffs in the UK: Bletchley Park.

Even back when I visited it, the Park was in a dismal state, badly preserved, run down — definitely far from what it should be, given both the fact that sixty years ago it was a British Government secret installation and its immense importance in World War II — and all that in a country whose culture even today is still fundamentally affected (I’d dare say defined) by the two World Wars. Today, about 8 years since my visit to Bletchley Park, I read at Bruce Schneier’s blog that it may close in a few years due to lack of funds. Having grown up in Hellas, a country with a long history and thousands of ancient sites all over the country, I always thought that the dismal state of Hellenic antiquities was due to the country’s deeply rooted nepotism, corruption, stupidity, indifference and total incapacity for efficient, constructive work. While the British government has quite frequently showed that it’s not far from the Hellenic one, one would expect that they’d care more to preserve a small-ish park and a Victorian mansion.

If you appreciate 20th century history and/or cryptography and are visiting the UK (or, better yet, live there), pay a visit to Bletchley Park. The tour may be somewhat indifferent to many, the park itself may be run down, but you’d be seeing first hand the place where Enigma was systematically deciphered during the war and — through your purchase of a ticket and or other souvernirs or donations — will help preserve a piece of modern history. Finally for all those interesting in computing, Bletchley Park hosts a small, and seemingly uninteresting computer museum; this is nothing like some of its counterparts in the U.S.. Nevertheless it has a unique exhibit that’s bound to thrill every computer scientist, programmer, engineer or geek visiting it: a working replica of Colossus.

For more information about the Park go to their page here or visit its Wikipedia entry.

1 comments

2006.07.15

Inflaming the Middle East

The Israeli-Palæstinian conflict is now more than sixty years old. It’s clear to all, but the most extreme nationalists (of both involved nations) or naïve idealists (globally) that the only viable solution, at least for the coming decades, would be a two-state division of what is currently Israel and its occupied territories. That is the plan. It would have been pretty straightforward to implement. But it doesn’t happen. Extremists on both sides make sure it doesn’t. Israel invokes the right to self-defence when attacking large parts of the Palæstinian (and now Lebanese) population and arab militants find excuses to launch their small and medium sized rockets to Israeli cities. Yet Israel and the arab extremists are not the sole parties to blame for their excessive actions over the past twenty years. It’s largely the fault of the U.N. and the international community that stands by while countless resolutions condemning both Israel’s actions get torpedoed by the U.S., generations of children on both sides grow among dead relatives and destruction, terrorist attacks continue in Israel fuelling religious extremism and nationalism. And there we go again.
»

4 comments

Download Spinalonga's Podsafe rock music for your podcast. From Athens, Greece, with love.'